Minnesota House of Representatives
Public Information Services


Public Information Services Menu

House doesn't budge, leaving transportation negotiations in neutral

By Jonathan Avise
Interstate 94 near downtown St. Paul. House Photography file photo

House Republicans on Wednesday countered a Senate offer on long-term transportation funding, sticking close to their initial plan passed last year and again ruling out an increase to the state’s gas tax as a part of any comprehensive agreement.

The House’s latest offer to the conference committee on HF4 showed little movement toward a compromise position with the DFL-led Senate, continuing to rely heavily on a shift of motor vehicle-related sales tax revenues from the state’s General Fund toward road and bridge projects, as well as using one-time dollars from the state’s projected $900 million budget surplus.

It also proposes no new dollars for metro area transit, tying any future funding increases to major changes to Metropolitan Council and transit governance.

“This offer represents our core road and bridge offer from 2015,” said Rep. Tim Kelly (R-Red Wing), chair of the House Transportation Policy and Finance Committee. House Republicans, he added, have “stayed consistent in (their) priorities.”

Rep. Tim Kelly, chair of the House Transportation Policy and Finance Committee, outlines a House offer during a May 11 meeting of the transportation conference committee. Sen. Scott Dibble, right, chair of the Senate Transportation and Public Safety Committee, listens. Photo by Paul Battaglia

With less than 12 days until the Legislature must adjourn, the new offer still leaves House Republicans and Senate DFLers with a yawning gap to bridge if they're to strike a long-sought transportation deal.

Senate transportation committee chair Scott Dibble (DFL-Mpls) took a small step toward the House position in an offer last week, backing off his caucus’ proposal to institute a new wholesale fuel tax that would raise the state tax on gasoline by at least 16 cents per gallon, and instead pitching a 12-cent hike in the state’s current per-gallon gas tax.

Kelly reiterated Wednesday a gas tax is something his side of the aisle will refuse to consider as part of any agreement.

Dibble indicated he believed the House’s offer is essentially unchanged from its initial stance.

“I do feel like this offer is fairly non-responsive to our good faith offer,” he said following the hearing.


In the same ballpark?

Gov. Mark Dayton and DFL leaders said this week that transportation — with Department of Transportation studies showing more than $10 billion in road and bridge needs over the next decade —has to be resolved first before other big session pieces like taxes and bonding fall into place.

A member of the audience follows along with the House offer sheet during a May 11 meeting of the transportation conference committee. Photo by Paul Battaglia

But, despite Dibble saying the two sides are “kind of in the same ballpark,” the opposing plans still look very different.

The Republican-backed plan relies on redirecting motor vehicle-related tax revenue away from the state’s General Fund, identifying efficiencies in the MnDOT budget, and utilizing $300 million of the state’s projected $900 million budget surplus in 2017 to increase transportation funding.

Meanwhile, the DFL-backed Senate bill proposes to generate more dollars for roads, bridges and transit by phasing in a gas tax hike over three years, increasing tab fees, and expanding a metro area sales tax to fund transit projects.

The House’s latest offer still includes no long-term investment in metro area transitways, including the proposed Southwest Light Rail line that stands to lose federal funding without state dollars.

Instead, it calls for reforms to the Metropolitan Council that include staggered terms for commissioners, the inclusion of local elected officials on the council and elected officials on the council’s nominating committee.

The House offer also proposes changes to how Twin Cities transit projects and rail lines are financed, including requiring legislative approval for major transitways, eliminating state dollars for light rail capital and operation costs and increasing how much revenue Metro Transit collects from fares.

“Before we can even talk about new revenue for transit, we are adamant that we talk about reforms to the Met Council,” Kelly said. 

Search Session Daily

Priority Dailies

'Inefficient and efficient at the same time': It’s conference committee season

Legislation packed with new or changing policies and billions in state-funded programs have made ...

Recent Dailies

Week in Review: April 24-28

A week heavy on conference committees continuing to work through differences between House and Se...

House, Senate agree to budget targets — now seek common ground with governor

The House and Senate Republican leaders on Friday unveiled their realigned budget targets as the ...

Less than $1 million in total funding separates House, Senate Legacy bills

Members of the omnibus legacy conference committee learned Thursday they won’t have a large fundi...

House tries again to rein in ‘drive-by’ disability-rights lawsuits

The House has taken another stab at stopping so-called “drive-by lawsuits” filed under statutes m...

House acts to freeze property owners’ ‘duty of care’ to trespassers

Current limits on an injured trespasser’s ability to sue should be set in statute and shouldn’t c...

House wants children in foster care to know their rights

Children at least age 10 in foster care might have to be informed of their right to a no-cost att...

House hems in condo-owner litigation over construction defects

Condominium associations and similar organizations would have to clear a higher bar before they f...

House votes to allow cancellation of condo purchases via email

You could use any agreed upon form of electronic communication to call off buying a condominium o...

Tax provision making ‘zapper’ use a felony passes House

A so-called technical bill, HF1226, put forward by the Department of Revenue, was passed by the H...

Changes to MnDOT land conveyance process pass the House

The Department of Transportation could offer the sale of excess trunk highway land to adjacent la...

Governor, legislative leaders remain at budget impasse

Gov. Mark Dayton said Wednesday that legislators must reconcile differences in major House and Se...

Both savings, spending measures differ in HHS omnibus bills

Both the House and Senate omnibus health and human services bills contain cuts intended to rein i...

Conferees on jobs and energy begin to iron out their differences

The House and Senate omnibus jobs and energy bills make an odd couple. The House version sprawls ...

House passes measure to require licensure of abortion clinics

Providers of abortions could need a license from the state to operate. A new licensure progra...

Public Information Services  ·   175 State Office Building, Saint Paul, MN 55155   ·   Public.Information@house.mn