Judge rules Dayton’s veto of Legislative funding violated constitution

By Jonathan Avise
House Speaker Kurt Daudt speaks with the media Wednesday after a Ramsey County district court judge ruled in favor of the Legislature in their suit over Gov. Mark Dayton’s line-item veto of House and Senate funding. Photo by Paul Battaglia

(Updated 3:19 p.m.)

A Ramsey County judge on Wednesday ruled that Gov. Mark Dayton’s line-item veto of legislative funding violated the state’s constitution, a victory for House and Senate leaders who had filed suit in an effort to have the maneuver overturned.

Dayton, a DFLer, had eliminated funding for the House and Senate from a state government finance bill in an effort to bring leaders of the Republican-controlled Legislature back to the negotiating table over provisions included in other budget bills the governor had signed into law.

Ramsey County Court Chief Judge John Guthmann wrote in his judgment that Dayton “improperly used his line-item veto authority to gain a repeal or modification of unrelated policy legislation by effectively eliminating a co-equal branch of government.”

That, the judge wrote, “offended the Separation of Powers clause of the Minnesota Constitution.”

MORE View the full court ruling

House Speaker Kurt Daudt (R-Crown) praised the ruling and encouraged the governor to not appeal.

“The bottom line is Minnesotans won today,” he said during an afternoon news conference on the Capitol steps. "The court very firmly overturned the governor's unconstitutional line-item vetoes of legislative funding — they made the right decision — and we've known that all along. Unfortunately, we had to go to court to right this wrong but we're happy for Minnesotans that their voice here at the Capitol has been restored." 

WATCH The speaker addresses the media following the ruling

In a statement, Dayton said he planned to appeal the decision to the Minnesota Supreme Court, calling Wednesday's ruling "a preliminary step in this case's judicial process." 

The governor repeated his belief that the tax bill passed by the Legislature — and that he signed into law — jeopardizes the state's structurally-balanced budget. Dayton again called for lawmakers to return to negotiations with him to reverse "fiscally irresponsible" tax cuts. 

"I will continue to fight for fiscally sound budgets and policies that benefit all Minnesotans," he said. 

Search Session Daily

Advanced Search Options

Priority Dailies

Mediation ordered to work out legislative, gubernatorial funding dispute
By Mike Cook

The Minnesota Supreme Court has ordered the Legislature and Gov. Mark Dayton to use mediation to resolve a funding dispute. In an opinion issued Friday, the court also ruled that Dayton’s use of the line-item veto to strip biennial funding for the Legislature was constitutional.

Judge rules Dayton’s veto of Legislative funding violated constitution
By Jonathan Avise

A Ramsey County judge on Wednesday ruled that Gov. Mark Dayton’s line-item veto of legislative funding violated the state’s constitution.

House, Senate head toward lawsuit over governor's legislative funding veto
By Jonathan Avise

House and Senate leadership OK a resolution to seek outside legal representation in an effort to restore funding for the Legislature that Gov. Mark Dayton line-item vetoed earlier this week.

Weary lawmakers pass final budget bills, wrap 2017 special session
By Mike Cook

Day three of the 2017 special session saw lawmakers pass final omnibus bills to be sent to Gov. Mark Dayton, with weary House members wrapping up their work at 2:42 a.m. Friday following a week of long days — and nights — at the State Capitol.

'Inefficient and efficient at the same time': It’s conference committee season
By Ricky Campbell

Lawmakers on conference committees must sort through competing bills before finalizing a product to send to the governor.

Omnibus bills provide framework for the state's biennial budget plan
By Ricky Campbell

The budget process explained — and why it matters

Dayton’s budget proposal prioritizes health, education and transportation
By Ricky Campbell

$45 billion plan is about a 10 percent increase over current biennium

Dayton proposes $1.5 billion bonding bill
By Jonathan Avise

Governor urges lawmakers to pass a big capital investment bill during budget-setting year; House Speaker has expressed doubt over bonding this session

Session opens with a number of unresolved issues
By HPIS Staff

It was a day of selfies, swearings-in and standing ovations as the House opened the 2017­-18 biennial session Tuesday.