Voting along party lines, a House division approved a $61.4 million package of environmental projects to be paid for by appropriations from the Environmental and Natural Resources Trust Fund.
The House Environment and Natural Resources Finance Division voted 11-7 Tuesday to refer HF4498, as amended, to the House Ways and Means Committee after Republican members failed in a bid to add $1.5 million in wastewater treatment grants for small towns to the bill.
The bill comprises most of the preliminary recommendations considered by the Legislative-Citizen Commission on Minnesota Resources, a 17-member legislative and citizen committee that recommends projects to the Legislature and was created after voters established the trust fund in 1988. The fund uses state lottery proceeds to protect, conserve, preserve and enhance the state’s air, water, land, fish, wildlife and other natural resources.
Rep. Rick Hansen (DFL-South St. Paul), the bill sponsor and division chair, said the package of projects garnered 10 votes on the LCCMR but did not get 12, the super-majority required for approval. However, this isn’t the first time the LCCMR didn’t get enough votes to make a formal recommendation.
“I think this is a good bill,” he said. “I think it responds to the emerging crisis and we’re able as a Legislature to respond quickly to those needs.”
The appropriations in the package include:
[MORE: View the spreadsheet]
Failed wastewater amendment
Rep. Tama Theis (R-St. Cloud) offered her support, saying tax revenue is down so much in those communities due to the coronavirus pandemic shutdown that city officials aren’t sure how they’ll start up again and also take care of wastewater issues.
But Becca Nash, director of the LCCMR, said there is some concern among commission members that the funds can only be allowed for loans, not grants.
Heintzeman believes grants are constitutional, even though environmental groups threatened to sue the state in 2018 when the Republican-controlled Legislature passed a bill using some of the trust fund for water infrastructure projects. The state backed off, but he wishes it had been settled in the courts.
“There’s a lot of money here available at the LCCMR and it goes to many, many good projects. This is also a very good project,” Heintzeman said. “We’re talking about facility upgrades for those small communities, which in many cases discharge wastewater directly into the Mississippi and other rivers … around the state of Minnesota. If you are ever going to clean water, which is part of the responsibility of the LCCMR, this is a phenomenal way to do it.”
Hansen said he didn’t include that funding due to constitutional concerns, and the documented history of concern about wastewater treatment consuming the entire environmental fund.
“We know that wastewater treatment is important,” he said, but added he also expects some federal funds for the facilities to come with coronavirus aid.
Rep. Jean Wagenius (DFL-Mpls) said Gov. Tim Walz has a generous amount of funding for wastewater infrastructure in his proposed bonding bill.