MINUTES
Representative Phil Krinkie, Chair of the Taxes Committee, called the twenty-fifth meeting to order at 8:15 a.m. on Thursday, April 28, 2005, in Room 200 of the State Office Building.
The Clerk noted the roll.
Members present:
KRINKIE, Phil, Chair KNOBLACH, Jim
SIMPSON, Dean, Vice Chair KOENEN, Lyle
ABRAMS, Ron KOHLS, Paul
ANDERSON, Irv LANNING, Morrie
ATKINS, Joe LENCZEWSKI, Ann
BERNARDY, Connie LESCH, John
BROD, Laura MARQUART, Paul
DAVIDS, Greg MULLERY, Joe
DAVNIE, Jim NELSON, Peter
DELAFOREST, Chris RUKAVINA, Tom
DILL, David SIEBEN, Katie
DORMAN, Dan VANDEVEER, Ray
ERHARDT, Ron WESTERBERG, Andy
HOWES, Larry ZELLERS, Kurt
JAROS, Mike
Members excused:
A quorum was present.
Chairman Krinkie moved HF 872 to be passed and re-referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Testifying were:
Greg Crowe; Minnesota House of Representative Fiscal Analyst
Tim Strom; Minnesota Department of Education
David Janson; Concerned Citizen
Bill Srusinski; Minnesota Service Cooperatives
Representative Dorman moved that the amendment labeled H0872A43 be adopted and incorporated into HF 872.
Representative Lesch requested a roll-call vote on the amendment labeled H0872A43.
Representative Lenczewski moved to divide the amendment labeled H0872A43 by acting on lines 1-3 and 4-7 separately.
Representative Lenczewski withdrew her request for division of the amendment.
Representative Lenczewski moved to orally amend the amendment labeled H0872A43 by deleting lines 3 and 4 and inserting “page 32, line 8 and delete the new language and reinstate the stricken language”
Representative Lesch requested a roll-call vote on the Lenczewski oral amendment.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Anderson Krinkie
Atkins Abrams
Bernardy Brod
Davnie Davids
Dill DeLaForest
Dorman Erhardt
Jaros Howes
Koenen Knoblach
Lenczewski Kohls
Lesch Lanning
Marquart Nelson
Mullery Simpson
Rukavina Vandeveer
Seiben Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 14 AYES AND 15 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Dorman renewed his motion that the amendment labeled H0872A43 be adopted as amended and incorporated into HF 872.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Anderson Krinkie
Dill Abrams
Dorman Atkins
Jaros Bernardy
Koenen Brod
Lesch Davids
Marquart Davnie
Rukavina DeLaForest
Erhardt
Howes
Knoblach
Kohls
Lanning
Lenczewski
Mullery
Nelson
Sieben
Simpson
Vandeveer
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 8 AYES AND 21 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Bernardy moved that the amendment labeled H0872A37 be adopted and incorporated into HF 872.
Representative Vandeveer moved to amend the amendment labeled H0872A37 with the amendment labeled H0872A45.
Representative Davnie requested a roll call vote on the amendment labeled H0872A45
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Krinkie Anderson Dorman
Abrams Atkins
Brod Bernardy
Davids Davnie
DeLaForest Dill
Erhardt Jaros
Howes Koenen
Knoblach Lenczewski
Kohls Lesch
Lanning Marquart
Nelson Mullery
Simpson Rukavina
Vandeveer Sieben
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 15 AYES AND 13 NAYS THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Abrams requested a roll call vote on the amendment labeled H0872A37.
Representative Bernardy withdrew the amendment labeled H0872A37.
The committee stood in recess to the call of the chair at10:30 AM.
Chairman Krinkie reconvened the meeting at 10:40 PM.
Representative Bernardy moved that the amendment labeled H0872A36 be adopted and incorporated into HF 872.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Chairman Krinkie renewed his motion that HF 872 as amended be passed and re-referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Representative Davnie requested a roll-call vote on HF 872 as amended.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Krinkie Anderson
Abrams Atkins
Brod Bernardy
Davids Davnie
DeLaForest Jaros
Dorman Koenen
Erhardt Lenczewski
Howes Lesch
Knoblach Marquart
Kohls Mullery
Lanning Rukavina
Nelson Sieben
Simpson
Vandeveer
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 16 AYES AND 12 NAYS THE MOTION PREVAILED.
Representative Lenczewski moved to reconsider the motion to pass HF 872 as amended and re-refer it to the Committee and Ways and Means.
Representative Lenczewski requested a roll-call vote on the motion to reconsider HF 872.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Krinkie
Abrams
Anderson
Atkins
Bernardy
Brod
Davids
Davnie
DeLaForest
Dill
Dorman
Erhardt
Howes
Jaros
Knoblach
Koenen
Kohls
Lanning
Lenczewski
Lesch
Marquart
Mullery
Nelson
Rukavina
Sieben
Simpson
Vandeveer
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 29 AYES AND 0 NAYS THE MOTION PREVAILED.
The committee stood in recess to the call of the chair at 10:58AM.
The committee reconvened at 8:33PM.
Representative Rukavina moved that the amendment labeled HAD-110 be adopted and incorporated into HF 872.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Rukavina moved that the amendment labeled H0872A38 be adopted and incorporated into HF 872.
THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Davnie moved that the amendment labeled H0872A55 be adopted and incorporated into HF 872.
Representative Davnie orally amended the amendment labeled H0872A55 by inserting on page 1, line 7 after “cooperative” the words “or health insurance company” and inserting on page 1, line 11 after “cooperative” the words “or health insurance company”.
Representative Davnie orally amended the amendment labeled H0872A55 by inserting on page 1, line 7 after “PROHIBITED.]” the words “Within 90 days of a renewal date”.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED AS AMENDED.
Chairman Krinkie renewed his motion that HF 872 as amended be passed and re-referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Representative Rukavina requested a roll call vote on HF 872 as amended.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Krinkie Anderson
Abrams Atkins
Brod Bernardy
Davids Davnie
DeLaForest Dill
Dorman Jaros
Erhardt Koenen
Howes Lenczewski
Knoblach Lesch
Kohls Marquart
Lanning Mullery
Nelson Rukavina
Simpson Sieben
Vandeveer
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 16 AYES AND 13 NAYS THE MOTION PREVAILED.
Representative Abrams moved HF 2461 to be passed and re-referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Testifying were:
John Walz; Minnesota House of Representatives Fiscal Analyst
Representative Davids moved that the amendment labeled H2641A18 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Representative Davids orally amended the amendment labeled H2641A18 by deleting on page 1, line 2 “149” and inserting “8”, and deleting on page 1, line 2 “20” and inserting “8”, and inserting on page 1, line 14 inserting after “signs.” the words “Renumber the remaining sections.”
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED AS AMENDED.
Representative Abrams moved that the amendment labeled H2641A46 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Davids moved that the amendment labeled H2641A34 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Simpson moved that the amendment labeled A05-0754be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Representative Simpson orally amended the amendment labeled A05-0754 by deleting on page 1, line 1 “first” and inserting “second”, on page 1, line 2 delete “22” and insert “16”, and on page 1, line 6 delete “46” and insert “45”.
Representative Abrams requested a roll-call vote on the amendment labeled A05-0754 as amended.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Anderson, I Krinkie Lenczewski
Atkins Abrams
Bernardy Brod
Davids DeLaForest
Davnie Knoblach
Dill Kohls
Dorman Vandeveer
Erhardt Zellers
Howes
Jaros
Koenen
Lanning
Lesch
Marquart
Mullery
Nelson
Rukavina
Seiben
Simpson
Westerberg
WITH 20 AYES AND 8 NAYS THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED AS AMENDED.
Representative Anderson moved that the amendment labeled A05-0749 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Representative Anderson orally amended the amendment labeled A05-0749 by deleting on page 1, line 1 “first” and inserting “second”, deleting on page 1, line 3 “87” and inserting “86”, deleting on page 1, line 3 “13” and inserting “2”, deleting on page 1, line 4 “Sec. 2.” and inserting “Sec 1.”, deleting on page 2, line 9 “89” and inserting “88”, and deleting on page 2, line 9 “26” and inserting “15”.
Representative Davnie moved the amendment labeled H2462A41 to be adopted and incorporated into the amendment labeled A05-0749.
THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Erhardt moved division of the amendment labeled A05-0749 between lines 8 and 9 on page 2.
Representative Erhardt requested the latter half of the bill be addressed first.
THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Anderson requested a roll call vote.
Representative Erhardt requested the first half of the bill be addressed last.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Anderson Krinkie Atkins
Brod Abrams Dorman
Davids Bernardy
Dill Davnie
Erhardt DeLaForest
Jaros Howes
Koenen Knoblach
Lenczewski Kohls
Rukavina Lanning
Seiben Lesch
Westerberg Marquart
Mullery
Nelson
Simpson
Vandeveer
Zellers
WITH 11 AYES AND 16 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Chairman Krinkie moved that the amendment labeled H2461A40 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Chairman Krinkie requested a roll-call vote on the amendment H2461A40.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Krinkie Abrams Dorman
Atkins Anderson
Brod Bernardy
Davnie Davids
DeLaForest Dill
Knoblach Erhardt
Kohls Howes
Marquart Jaros
Mullery Koenen
Simpson Lanning
Vandeveer Lenczewski
Westerberg Lesch
Zellers Nelson
Rukavina
Seiben
WITH 13 AYES AND 15 NAYS, THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Lanning moved that the amendment labeled H2461A44 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Brod moved that the amendment labeled H2461A47 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Mullery moved that the amendment labeled H2461A18 as it was amended to be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Representative Mullery amended the amendment labeled H2461A18 by inserting language to install a sign for the North Mississippi Regional Park at the 49th Ave Exit of I-94.
THE MOTION PREVAILED. THE AMENDMENT WAS ADOPTED.
Representative Vandeveer moved that the amendment labeled HRD be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Representative DeLaForest requested a roll call vote on the amendment labeled HRD.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Erhardt Krinkie Dorman
Howes Abrams
Jaros Anderson
Mullery Atkins
Nelson Bernardy
Seiben Brod
Vandeveer Davids
Davnie
DeLaForest
Dill
Knoblach
Koenen
Kohls
Lanning
Lenczewski
Lesch
Marquart
Rukavina
Simpson
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 7 AYES AND 21 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Vandeveer moved that the amendment labeled H2461A30 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Representative Vandeveer requested a roll call vote on the amendment labeled H2461A30.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Howes Krinkie Dorman
Koenen Abrams
Vandeveer Anderson
Atkins
Bernardy
Brod
Davids
Davnie
DeLaForest
Dill
Erhardt
Jaros
Knoblach
Kohls
Lanning
Lenczewski
Lesch
Marquart
Mullery
Nelson
Rukavina
Seiben
Simpson
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 3 AYES AND 25 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Vandeveer moved that the amendment labeled H2461A29 be adopted and incorporated into HF 2641.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Davnie Krinkie Dorman
Howes Abrams
Koenen Anderson
Mullery Atkins
Rukavina Bernardy
Seiben Brod
Vandeveer Davids
DeLaForest
Dill
Erhardt
Knoblach
Kohls
Lanning
Lenczewski
Lesch
Marquart
Nelson
Simpson
Westerberg
Zellers
WITH 8 AYES AND 20 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL. THE AMENDMENT WAS NOT ADOPTED.
Representative Abrams renewed his motion HF 2461 to be passed as amended and re-referred to the Committee on Ways and Means.
Chairman Krinkie requested a roll call vote on the passage of the bill.
Those voting in the affirmative: Those voting in the negative: Those abstaining:
Abrams Krinkie Dorman
Brod Anderson
Davids Atkins
DeLaForest Bernardy
Erhardt Davnie
Howes Dill
Kohls Jaros
Lanning Knoblach
Nelson Koenen
Simpson Lenczewski
Westerberg Lesch
Zellers Marquart
Mullery
Rukavina
Sieben
Vandeveer
WITH 12 AYES AND 16 NAYS THE MOTION DID NOT PREVAIL.
The committee adjourned at 11:59 p.m.
REP. PHIL KRINKIE, CHAIR
Jeremy J Estenson
Committee Legislative Assistant