Minnesota House of Representatives
Public Information Services


Public Information Services Menu

Ed finance omnibus bill conference committee digs into details, seeks unified proposal

By Nick Longworth
Rep. Jenifer Loon, chair of the House Education Finance Committee, left, and Sen. Carla Nelson, chair of the Senate E-12 Finance Committee, confer before the start of the first meeting of the conference committee on HF890, the omnibus education finance bill April 19. Photo by Paul Battaglia

With the fate of voluntary pre-kindergarten programs across the state to be determined, a House-Senate conference committee met Wednesday to discuss details in proposed legislation that has split lawmakers down the aisle this session.

A conference committee meeting detailed the differences in the two omnibus education finance bills. Nonpartisan House and Senate staff reviewed the bills side-by-side for comparison.

The House passed HF890*/ SF718, sponsored by Rep. Jenifer Loon (R-Eden Prairie), 75-56 March 31. The Senate amended and passed the bill 38-28 April 4. Sen. Carla Nelson (R-Rochester) is the Senate sponsor.

The House proposal would increase the General Education Basic Formula funding by 1.25 percent over the 2018-19 biennium, or $205.9 million in additional funding. The Senate would increase the formula by 1.5 percent, a $298.6 million increase.

“We have an opportunity to really invest in our kids and our shared future,” Education Commissioner Brenda Cassellius told the conferees.

But both bills contain numerous policy provisions, something that Gov. Mark Dayton has said he doesn’t want to be included in omnibus finance bills.

Both versions would allow school boards to adopt “E-learning days” in lieu of the long-held “snow day” during inclement weather. Districts could provide electronic instruction and count the day on its instructional hour calendar.

The proposals would each implement the teacher licensure overhaul originally proposed in HF140, dissolving the Board of Teaching into the Professional Educator Licensing and Standards Board, and create a four-tier licensure system.


Pushing policy

The defunding of voluntary pre-k is the most prominent policy provision to catch the ire of the governor. Currently, $25 million in base funding serves an estimated 3,300 4-year-olds at 74 school districts.

Dayton’s budget recommendation would increase biennial spending to $175 million, but under  House and Senate bills, it would go unfunded — replaced instead by $48 million in school readiness adjustment credits and $24.6 million for early learning scholarships.

Another controversial provision would require a school board to negotiate an unrequested leave of absence plan with teacher representatives, and eliminate the use of seniority as a basis of proficiency. It would essentially abolish the so-called “last-in-first-out” policy governing teacher terminations.

Both bills offer several different policy provisions, albeit often uncontentious. The House version would:

  • require school districts to accurately and efficiently test for the presence of lead in water;
  • delink compensatory revenue from the General Education Basic Formula;
  • create a new targeted compensatory revenue of $11 million for Fiscal Year 2018 and $12.3 million for Fiscal Year 2019 and thereafter for the purpose of closing the opportunity gap by increasing student proficiency rates;
  • abolish the Perpich Center for Arts Education effective June 30, 2018, and convey the Crosswinds Arts and Science School for use as a metropolitan area integration school;
  • establish a Lola and Rudy Perpich arts education and outreach division to provide arts support services to school districts throughout Minnesota;
  • create a legislative study group on school finance;
  • require that a school district performance report include calculated proficiency rates as required by the most recently reauthorized Elementary and Secondary Education Act;
  • allow a student enrolled in a post-secondary enrollment option to remain at a school site during a school day;
  • include child sexual abuse prevention instruction in health curriculum (known as Erin’s Law);
  • require a school district to have an individualized education program for each child with a disability at the beginning of each school year; and
  • include government and citizenship instruction in compulsory curriculum.

The Senate version would:

  • require a school district to maintain monthly utility consumption data;
  • establish the Educational Stability for Students in Foster Care pilot program;
  • require a district to annually notify the parent of a student who is not reading at their grade level regarding their proficiency and the services being provided; and
  • establish the Innovation Zone program to improve student and school outcomes consistent with the World’s Best Workforce.

Public testimony is expected to be taken at a future hearing.

Search Session Daily

Recent Dailies

Week in Review: April 17-21

When lawmakers return Monday, they will have four weeks to work with Gov. Mark Dayton in crafting...

$61 million and plenty of policy separates House, Senate state government bills

A committee of 10 legislators – five from the House, five from the Senate – began working Friday ...

Funding differences, concerns aplenty as public safety conferees begin their work

When combined, the House and Senate proposed increases in public safety and judiciary funding for...

Government audits of insurance companies gets House OK

After surfacing complaints from the insurance industry about how the Department of Commerce condu...

Bill subjecting commission sales reps to state law passes House

The House passed a bill Thursday that would close a loophole that businesses based in other state...

House passes data changes, background checks for appraisers

The House on Thursday passed a bill that would make a number of technical changes to laws governi...

Cost-saving measure for credit unions, members now moves to Senate

Credit unions would be able to embrace technology and encourage members to show up for meetings a...

Higher Ed conference group begins to hash out policy differences

Tasked with crafting a proposal that would offer affordability and accessibility for post-seconda...

House OKs limits to life insurance policies by suspected terrorists

Insurance companies may be able to limit life insurance payments to beneficiaries of suspected te...

House recognizes research, fiscal departments for 50 years of service

The non-partisan House Research and House Fiscal Analysis Departments were recognized by the Hous...

Omnibus tax bill repurposes some 2016 vetoed provisions, adds some new

There hasn’t been a comprehensive omnibus tax bill since 2013 when Gov. Mark Dayton instituted a ...

House, Senate negotiators tackle transportation bills in hopes of finding a deal

Can Minnesota lawmakers reach a long-discussed, long-term transportation funding deal? House and ...

'Inefficient and efficient at the same time': It’s conference committee season

Legislation packed with new or changing policies and billions in state-funded programs have made ...

Buffer law, fee increases on table as environment conference committee starts

Fee increases at state parks, delays in the buffer law, even who can use scopes on muzzleloaders,...

Panel hears how Real ID compliance bills differ

How Minnesota might comply with the federal Real ID law — an issue that has dogged the Legislatur...

House minority leader responds with own protest and dissent

House Minority Leader Melissa Hortman (DFL-Brooklyn Park) submitted her own two-page protest and ...

House ethics panel stands at ready to self-police

Disputes over government ethics have been roiling politics around the globe this year, from Washi...

Starting Line: Seeking ways to prevent wolf-livestock conflicts in Greater Minnesota

According to the Department of Natural Resources, Minnesota has the highest population of wolves ...

With five weeks to go, lots for 2017 Legislature to get accomplished

When legislators return to St. Paul next week after the week-long Passover/Easter break it is exp...

Public Information Services  ·   175 State Office Building, Saint Paul, MN 55155   ·   Public.Information@house.mn