Minnesota House of Representatives
Public Information Services


Public Information Services Menu

'Inefficient and efficient at the same time': It’s conference committee season

By Ricky Campbell
House Speaker Kurt Daudt wants members who support an omnibus bill on a conference committee. Photo by Paul Battaglia

Legislation packed with new or changing policies and billions in state-funded programs have made their way through the committee process, through both the House and Senate and, because of discrepancies in their wording and funding, now have to go through another similar cycle.

Because language in the House version differs from the Senate version in each of these omnibus bills, a new panel with up to 10 legislators, usually representing both parties, must determine what a final bill will look like before each chamber approves it and sends it to the governor. In the next few weeks, the legislative calendar is likely to be brimming with conference committees.

A conference committee consists of three to five members from each chamber – often called “conferees” – tasked with reconciling differences between House and Senate proposed legislation. It’s another round of committee-like work, with additional chances for outside input as legislators head into the session’s homestretch.

Joint rules outline what the conference committees can and can’t do. For instance, conference committees can’t schedule meetings between midnight and 7 a.m., but can vote to extend their meetings past midnight; or chairs must rotate between representatives and senators every calendar day.

Conference committees can’t appropriate more money than the initial bills or amendments included unless the House speaker and the Senate majority leader approve them. Additionally, conferees can’t add rulemaking power to agencies and departments unless they, too, were included in the House or Senate bill or amendments.

Rep. Sarah Anderson

If conferees agree, a written report is published. The report returns to both the House and the Senate for votes, beginning with the original chamber.

“This process is designed to be inefficient and efficient at the same time,” Rep. Sarah Anderson (R-Plymouth) said. “Inefficient in the sense that you need to make sure everybody has a voice in it, but efficient in the sense that that’s why we have committees in the first place – to have people focus on one area and bring it to the body as a whole.”

In the sports world, there are events like the Stanley Cup Playoffs and the NCAA basketball championships where teams live and die each round. In the Legislature, Anderson said, conference committees are “the semifinals” in the life of a bill.

So far this year, two conference committees met and passed reports. The first established a state-funded insurance relief package and the second implements a reinsurance program. Others started their work Tuesday and more will continue throughout session.


Committee membership

There aren’t any official rules dictating conference committee membership.

When House Speaker Kurt Daudt (R-Crown) appoints House members to conference committees, in the case of omnibus bills, he said he first looks at bill sponsors, vice-chairs of related committees and members with significant provisions in the bill.

DFL members who supported respective omnibus bills and who have been assigned to conference committees.

There is a trend for minority party members, too: If a member of the minority party votes for the original bill – this year, the number is scant of DFLers voting for Republican omnibus bills – they’re probably assigned to that omnibus bill’s committee.

Rep. Mary Murphy (DFL-Hermantown) was the only DFL member to vote for HF890*/ SF718, the education finance omnibus bill, and she was assigned to that conference committee. Likewise, Rep. Ilhan Omar (DFL-Mpls) joined every Republican in supporting HF2477/ SF2214*, the higher education finance package, and Rep. Jennifer Schultz (DFL-Duluth) was the lone minority vote in favor of HF945/ SF800*, the omnibus health and human services bill. They are both on those conference committees.

Asked about her vote on the bill and her conference committee membership, Murphy cited “past experience in education,” as one of the reasons Daudt might have appointed her to the committee.

“At this time, the economy of the state is good,” Murphy said. “I’d like to see education be the highest priority for the children of Minnesota… I’d like my voice heard.”

There are exceptions to that trend. Murphy was also the lone DFLer to vote for HF861, the omnibus transportation finance bill, but that conference committee’s House membership is comprised of all Republicans. Sen. Dan Sparks (DFL-Austin) is the only minority party representative.

Anderson chairs the House State Government Finance Committee, which produced what is now HF691/ SF605*. Not a single House DFLer voted for Anderson’s bill, and in turn, none are on that conference committee. Sen. Carolyn Laine (DFL-Columbia Heights) is the lone DFLer on the 10-person committee.

“Generally there is a belief in the Legislature – I don’t know if it stands for the Senate, but for the House at least the practice has been – if you do vote for the bill and you’re in the minority party, it increases your chances to serve on that conference committee,” Anderson said.

Daudt said flat-out that although “we want [DFL] input,” people who didn’t vote for the bill – minority and majority party members – don’t get a conferee spot.

“We put a Democrat on if a Democrat voted for the bill,” he said in an interview. “If no Democrats voted for it, no Democrats get to be on the conference committee. That’s been pretty standard operating procedure. If the minority doesn’t vote for it, they don’t get a spot on the conference committee.”

Omar is in a unique spot, too. While Senate Republicans have placed at least one first-timer on each of these committees, she is the only freshman House conferee.


High hopes

Rep. Mary Murphy

Some lawmakers assume bills with slight differences will automatically go through the conference committee process, like in January when Daudt and Rep. Joe Hoppe (R-Chaska) announced that conferees would best tailor the HF1/ SF1* insurance premium relief bill. Others end up in conference committees because of gaping differences in longstanding political battles, like the Real ID bill.

With the spending-and-policy-changing omnibus bills, however, conference committees usually have much more to compare. With that, every party is optimistic for their ideals to emerge.

Murphy said her efforts will focus on increasing education spending levels closer to Gov. Mark Dayton’s proposal than the Republican proposals passed by both chambers.

“Every conference committee is different,” Murphy said. “The conference committee depends on the personalities of the individuals, as well as the goals of the people of Minnesota – and in [our] case, the children of Minnesota.

“It’s not an easy task – it’s never easy – but there should be enough money to go around,” she said.

How to spend a $1.65 billion projected surplus is driving a wedge between the administration, which wants to increase spending on education, transportation and health care, and the Republican majorities controlling both legislative chambers, which emphasize reduced government programs and large reductions in tax collection.

Anderson said she and Sen. Mary Kiffmeyer (R-Big Lake) reached out to the administration, hoping for input on priorities, believing answers would quash any concerns from the governor. The governor’s appointees railed against Anderson’s bill during a committee hearing – and they will join the public with more input during conference committee meetings.

The ultimate goal is, of course, to get the bills signed into law.

“I’m excited about this process,” Anderson said. “It’s kind of like you get through the initial piece and now it’s like you get to kind of fine-tune things, if you will. So I’m looking forward to getting feedback from the senators and putting together a good product the governor will sign into law and – again, I can’t say this enough – I hope that he participates in the process and they don’t have a closed door to our thoughts in the Legislature.

“We all represent the same people he represents and so [I’m] just looking for his active participation in this process,” she added.

Daudt said he’s “pretty hands off” when it comes to conference committee details, leaving the lawmakers who heard public testimony and who talked to fellow legislators to dig into the minutiae. He’ll become more involved when it comes to negotiating with Dayton.

“We want to engage the governor in that process because we want to put bills on the governor’s desk that the governor will sign,” he said.

Oh, and if there’s anyone who thinks conference committees are a façade for smoke-filled backroom dealings ruled by an iron-fisted speaker, Daudt said that isn’t the case. “That happens almost never,” he said. 

Search Session Daily

Recent Dailies

Week in Review: April 17-21

When lawmakers return Monday, they will have four weeks to work with Gov. Mark Dayton in crafting...

$61 million and plenty of policy separates House, Senate state government bills

A committee of 10 legislators – five from the House, five from the Senate – began working Friday ...

Funding differences, concerns aplenty as public safety conferees begin their work

When combined, the House and Senate proposed increases in public safety and judiciary funding for...

Government audits of insurance companies gets House OK

After surfacing complaints from the insurance industry about how the Department of Commerce condu...

Bill subjecting commission sales reps to state law passes House

The House passed a bill Thursday that would close a loophole that businesses based in other state...

House passes data changes, background checks for appraisers

The House on Thursday passed a bill that would make a number of technical changes to laws governi...

Cost-saving measure for credit unions, members now moves to Senate

Credit unions would be able to embrace technology and encourage members to show up for meetings a...

Higher Ed conference group begins to hash out policy differences

Tasked with crafting a proposal that would offer affordability and accessibility for post-seconda...

House OKs limits to life insurance policies by suspected terrorists

Insurance companies may be able to limit life insurance payments to beneficiaries of suspected te...

House recognizes research, fiscal departments for 50 years of service

The non-partisan House Research and House Fiscal Analysis Departments were recognized by the Hous...

Omnibus tax bill repurposes some 2016 vetoed provisions, adds some new

There hasn’t been a comprehensive omnibus tax bill since 2013 when Gov. Mark Dayton instituted a ...

House, Senate negotiators tackle transportation bills in hopes of finding a deal

Can Minnesota lawmakers reach a long-discussed, long-term transportation funding deal? House and ...

Buffer law, fee increases on table as environment conference committee starts

Fee increases at state parks, delays in the buffer law, even who can use scopes on muzzleloaders,...

Ed finance omnibus bill conference committee digs into details, seeks unified proposal

With the fate of voluntary pre-kindergarten programs across the state to be determined, a House-S...

Panel hears how Real ID compliance bills differ

How Minnesota might comply with the federal Real ID law — an issue that has dogged the Legislatur...

House minority leader responds with own protest and dissent

House Minority Leader Melissa Hortman (DFL-Brooklyn Park) submitted her own two-page protest and ...

House ethics panel stands at ready to self-police

Disputes over government ethics have been roiling politics around the globe this year, from Washi...

Starting Line: Seeking ways to prevent wolf-livestock conflicts in Greater Minnesota

According to the Department of Natural Resources, Minnesota has the highest population of wolves ...

With five weeks to go, lots for 2017 Legislature to get accomplished

When legislators return to St. Paul next week after the week-long Passover/Easter break it is exp...

Week in Review: April 3-7

It took tired members about three hours to wrap up their week of lengthy floor debates by approvi...

House passes omnibus health bill that would scrap MNsure

The House passed its omnibus health and human services finance bill, as amended, on a 75-53 vote ...

Dayton demands fiscal integrity from lawmakers

With the Legislature poised to begin its Passover/Easter recess, Gov. Mark Dayton had a message f...

House OKs omnibus state government finance bill that reduces spending

A two-year, $944 million plan to fund state government agencies and offices passed the House 75-5...

House gives its blessing to omnibus jobs and energy bill

The omnibus job growth and energy affordability policy and finance bill would distribute $380 mil...

Student data on school laptops would get privacy protections

Students using school-issued laptops, tablets, and other devices could know their data has specia...

State reporting on abortions could expand to track telemedicine use

Annual state reports on induced abortions already include a lot of information – where the proced...

From home cooks to fences and feedlots, omnibus ag policy bill passes House

The financial threshold farmers must meet to participate in the state’s debt mediation program ma...

House unanimously passes omnibus agriculture finance bill

Money for farmer-led councils that could prompt more buy-in to the state’s buffer program is incl...

House passes ‘affordable, accountable’ higher education omnibus bill

Legislators this session are focused on providing affordability, accountability and accessibility...

House passes more than $500 million in Legacy appropriations

The House voted 131-0 to pass more than $500 million in Legacy appropriations Tuesday although co...

High school league rules on transfer student eligibility need clarity

In an effort to keep high school student-athletes from transferring schools to create unfair comp...

Omnibus public safety bill gets House OK; returns to Senate

Calling for a tougher penalty for freeway-blocking protesters, containing provisions for a potent...

Public Information Services  ·   175 State Office Building, Saint Paul, MN 55155   ·   Public.Information@house.mn